I spotted the image below on So Bad, So Good yesterday. In my view, it sums up the newspaper industry’s woes quite simply in terms of consumers being able to access a range of content for free from their pocket.
After seeing the image, I couldn’t help but remember Gerard Cunningham’s tweet from earlier in the day about the sad news announced by Landmark Media about voluntary redundancies at the Irish Examiner and its other regional titles.
Be honest: If you tweeted about the Landmark/Examiner layoffs, did you buy a paper today?
— Gerard Cunningham (@faduda) April 16, 2014
There was a bit of car crash radio on RTE a couple of weeks ago as Gerry Byrne and Declan Waugh were on Today With Sean O’Rourke, with Keelin Shanley standing in as presenter, to discuss fluoridation in Ireland. As part of the interview, Declan Waugh made the claim that fluoride was a factor in Down Syndrome levels in Ireland. Shanley immediately asked him to cite the research which supported this claim, which Waugh was unable to do and was admonished by the presenter for making such a claim on national radio without the evidence to back it up.
The anti-flouride lobby has made giant strides in making their cause a national issue, which frankly I’m amazed by considering all the scientific evidence which supports fluoridation. When it comes to science, however, media have been found quite wanting on a range of topics, whether its fluoridation or climate change due to succumbing to ‘false balance’ and giving opinions and scientific fact the same weight (this damning report – pdf – on the BBC’s coverage on climate change is well worth a read.)
Waugh could have at least made the claim, however, if he imply was able to reference the research he based his claim on. Whether it was a slip of the mind or simply a case of never being challenged by a journalist in the past, he floundered and rightly came in for criticism from Shanley. This single moment completely undermined him and he lost all credibility to the listener. So it just goes to show that if you want to position yourself as an expert, make sure you know your facts when you’re asked for them.
I was listening to NewsTalk’s Down To Business last Saturday as the show’s host, Bobby Kerr, interviewed Wayne Byrne from Oxymem, winners of the 2014 Innovation of the Year at the Irish Times & InterTradeIreland Innovation Awards (you can listen to the interview here about 22 minutes in.) Oxymem produce a piece of technology – a bubbleless aeration solution – for wastewater treatment, which isn’t the easiest thing to get your head around particularly on a Saturday morning.
As Wayne tried to explain what his company does to listeners, Bobby quickly jumped in with this classic line – “With all these things, I try to summarise them into one sentence and with your concept what I did was – it saves energy when it breaks down sewage.”
Simple and straight to the point. Exactly what you need when you’ve got a limited amount of time to explain what you or your product do.
We should all ask ourselves the question, can I explain what I do for a living in one sentence. The best audience to test your answer on is your mother, because if she understands then you know you’re on the right track.
First impressions count, particularly in broadcast interviews as if you lose your audience from the outset, then they are likely to drift off and not pay attention to what you are saying. Bobby played a blinder as the host by giving context to the audience for what Wayne’s product does, instantly making the interview more accessible.
So next time you are preparing for an interview, it’s worth bearing Bobby’s advice in mind and making sure you can explain what you do in one sentence.
Duncan Stewart’s interview on NewsTalk’s Breakfast Show this morning was one of those media performances where you’re left cringing (the full interview can be listened to on this link.) Stewart was on the show to discuss climate change and how media cover the topic in terms of the issues around false balance, something which I am in full agreement with Stewart about. Obviously very passionate about the topic, Stewart felt that the host, Shane Coleman, wasn’t giving him the platform to make his point and then threatened to walk out of the interview, eventually come out with a line that will be rolled out in media training seminars for years – ‘Give me 10 minutes or I’m not staying.’
What’s disappointing about Stewart’s initial outburst is that it lasts about ninety seconds (there is another heated debate towards the end of the interview between Stewart and Coleman’s co-host later), but it is the main focus of subsequent media coverage, deflecting focus from the discussion on climate change – the very issue Stewart was on to discuss!
From a media training perspective, Stewart broke one of the cardinal rules by becoming aggressive with the presenters. While the likes of Jeremy Paxman or Vincent Browne tearing strips off their guests may make for great entertainment, the reverse is rarely the case with listeners forming a poor impression of the interviewee.
The apparent confusion about the interview length is also something worth noting in terms of what your PR representative should establish before an interview. Interviewees should be clear on details like approximately how long the segment will take, who is interviewing them and whether there is anyone else being interviewed as part of the same segment.
Duncan Stewart does a great job to promote environmental issues, but this interview just goes to show that sometimes our passion can get the better of us. As Benjamin Franklin once said, “If passion drives you, let reason hold the reins.”
Independent Newspapers has signed on as official partner to FAI. As part of the arrangement, Independent.ie will get exclusive interviews and news from the FAI. It’ll be interesting to see what INM’s rivals will make of the partnership.
Phantom FM is no more and will be rebranded as TXFM, in a move which is meant to closely align the station with its stable mate Today FM. Although the news is disappointing, the station’s following had dwindled and had come in for some fair criticism – Jim Carroll has a good synopsis of Phantom’s decline.
The latest circulation figures for Irish print media revealed another bloodbath as sales continued to decline. The one exception, however, is the Irish Farmers Journal, which has actually grown by 5% since 2006. Its success highlights how a specialist product which isn’t given away for free can go from strength to strength commercially. One aspect of the Journal’s success which hasn’t attracted much attention has been the strength of its YouTube channel, with views for videos of farm machinery highlighting that there’s an untapped audience yet to be exploited.
There’s a new business radio show on NewsTalk, with The Currency airing for ten weeks on Sunday’s between 6-7pm, focusing on international business news.
Vincent Boland is the new Ireland correspondent for the Financial Times, after Jamie Smyth moved to become Australia and Pacific correspondent.
Michael O’Kane and Catherine Farrell are the new programme editors for RTE Radio 1 Morning Ireland.
Sean MacCeartaigh has left the Irish Examiner to join the production team of TV3′s Tonight With Vincent Browne.
Cystic Fibrosis campaigner and journalist Orla Tinsley has joined the Independent.ie team and will write a weekly column every Monday.
Another year, another launch of the Edelman Trust Barometer. Despite being around for approximately seventeen years now, the research never fails to spark interest and this year was no different. The 2014 findings were quite striking for me, primarily if you compare the results to previous years as they show that the great hope the Irish public had for change around the last general election has dissipated and levels of trust are around the same levels as 2011 (click the image for an enlarged view.)
The other striking result is the clear lack in trust by the public in politicians and business leaders across a range of actions, highlighting an embedded skepticism in society (click the image for an enlarged view.)
The launch event itself was quite stimulating with a thought provoking address from Dr Tom Clonan, who recounted his experience of serving in the Irish army in Lebanon, later as a whistleblower revealing the systematic sexual harassment of Irish women soldiers, and more recently his experience as a father of a disabled child.
Clonan’s account highlighted that we don’t do transparency well in Ireland and here is a clear need for reform across a variety of institutions in the country. He highlighted the lack of diversity in a range of areas in terms of political representation and media commentators. The same accusation could equally be made of the business world.
So where do we go from here? My colleague and Edelman Ireland chairman Jim Glennon summed it up best when he wrapped up the event with his comment – ‘You always learn a lot more from a defeat then you do from a victory.‘
We’ve essentially been through the wars in Ireland in terms of the collapse of the Celtic Tiger and revelations of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church. The crisis at the Central Remedial Clinic is just the latest in a series of scandals that has rocked the public conscious.
We essentially need to create a culture of transparency in order to rebuild trust in institutions. Tom Cloonan only had to point out the commentary around the Garda whistleblowers who presented to the Public Accounts Committee last week which shows that we still do not have an environment where whistleblowers can feel comfortable to come forward. A lot of work obviously still needs to be done if we hope to achieve this.
While there is clearly a link between economic performance and levels of trust, the positive signs around the Irish economy should not mean that we forego the continual self-examination to ensure we have learned from the mistakes of the past and also make sure that we put a system of accountability in place. As one of the panelists at the event, Simon Harris TD, said at the launch, “We don’t need a return to blind trust, we need a society that always probes.”
The spotlight on the Irish charity sector at the moment offers a unique insight in terms of the challenges and opportunities organisations in the space face. Clearly a lack of transparency on executive pay and poor governance by a handful of organisations has had a huge impact on the whole sector. As a result there is a requirement for executives involved in the running of charities to proactively communicate how they operate and demonstrate the results they are achieving.
There is also a requirement, however, for the public to also educate themselves better. Simon Harris made a good point about an exam he sat in school where he was asked what Mary Harney’s position in cabinet was at the time. Apart from having to know her title, there was no requirement for actually understanding what her role involved.
The danger of an unengaged public is that it sweeps through society. Dr Cloonan underlined this when he made a point about the lack of interrogation in the media about the era of austerity. Just as we didn’t question the fundamentals of the boom, we’re making the same mistakes again. One of the primary reasons for this is the lack of diversity in our political representation and in the media.
I’m reminded of an article on the New Statesman website about how the majority of media commentators are white men aged 50+ and the negative effect that has on discourse in society. I’ve highlighted a key quote from the piece below.
…for the time being the ancient kings still rule. The old make the news for the old, and politicians watch and obsess as if the images flickering across their screens are somehow relevant to the hopes, dreams and fears of the population they so dismally fail to represent.
The full research deck for the Edelman Ireland 2014 Trust Barometer can new viewed below. More commentary is available on the Edelman website.
A couple of PR stunts that caught my attention before the end of the year. Obviously enough they are mostly Christmas related.
The UK video game retailer GAME was quite busy trying to stay top of mind with consumers. The stunt which grabbed most publicity was their Christmas dinner in a can. Their tongue in cheek product aimed to cater for gamers who were too hooked on Christmas presents to tear themselves away for their dinner. The all-in-one Christmas dinner consisted of nine layers including turkey and potatoes, scrambled eggs and bacon, and mince pie. Not particularly appealing, but it generated wall-to-wall coverage.
PUMA’s personalised boots to announce their sponsorship of Mario Balotelli was inspired.
— Piaras Kelly (@pkellypr) December 23, 2013
Hats off to Waterstones who turned around this riposte to Amazon’s drone delivery announcement, which was made the night before.
Just thought I’d share some examples of corporates using social media in recent weeks.
Elon Musk recent used Tesla’s blog to counter a narrative that seemed to be gaining consensus in the mainstream media that the Tesla Model S, the firm’s flagship model, posed a greater fire risk than traditional vehicles. Musk took to the company blog to dispel the flaws inherit in this narrative and set out the company’s position. It’s a simple and effective tactic that more companies surprisingly don’t take advantage of. It is their own unedited platform and can be used to counter criticisms laid out against a company in the press.
Permanent TSB pursued a similar strategy after the announcement that the deposit and loan accounts of customers of Newbridge Credit Union had been transferred to the bank. A video statement by PTSB Group Chief Executive Jeremy Masding was posted to YouTube and offered to media during the course of the day to set out their position on the announcement.
BusinessWeek has dubbed 2014 the year of the paywall. In Ireland, it is certainly going to be a topic up for debate.
Both the Irish Times and Irish Independent have discussed launching paywalls, but it seems like a bit of a Mexican standoff as Irish media outlets try to figure out how to charge for content when free alternatives like RTE and TheJournal exist.
One outlet that has already taken the plunge is the Irish Sun. Unlike its UK counterpart, however, it hasn’t had the benefit of being able to offer Premiership Goals as a sweetener for subscribers. The Irish Sun’s editor, Paul Clarkson, tweeted over the weekend about content that it has secured and I wouldn’t be surprised if additional exclusive content is announced over the coming months.
Irish Sun secures Champions League and Europa footie from 2015. FA Cup, Celtic and Rangers action on your mobile too…
— Paul Clarkson (@PaulC_IrishSun) November 23, 2013
The question remains whether the lure of football highlights will draw in the paying punters. A similar strategy in the UK hasn’t gotten off to a great start and there is plenty of competition for content rights, particularly with BT seemingly intent on taking on all comers.
There are no recent tweets.
Musings about PR, Marketing, Advertising and Current Affairs by an Irish Public Relations Consultant
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
- July 2006
- June 2006
- May 2006
- April 2006
- March 2006
- February 2006
- January 2006
- December 2005
- November 2005
- October 2005
- September 2005
- August 2005
- July 2005
- June 2005
- May 2005
- One Image Which Sums Up Newspapers’ Woes
- If You Position Yourself As The Expert, Make Sure You Know Your Facts
- Can You Explain What You Do In A Sentence?
- Give Me 10 Minutes Or I’m Not Staying
- Irish Media News
- Irish Media Movement
- Edelman Ireland 2014 Trust Barometer
- Stuff That Caught My Attention #25
- Some Clever Use Of Social Media By Corporates
- Making Paywalls Pay